Shootouts

Head-to-head: Samsung HU9000 high-end curved vs. HU8500 flatscreen UHD TVs

By Katrina Canlas & Ng Chong Seng - 22 Sep 2014

Introduction & design

 

The year of 4K

The war between plasma and LCD is over, and LCD has won. While you might still be able to pick up one of the last great 1080p plasma sets somewhere, LCD (or rather, LED-based LCD) is your only choice if you’re shopping for a TV with 4K resolution.

Versus last year, buying a 4K TV today makes more sense. For one, most of the newer models have HDMI 2.0 inputs, which means they support 4K up to 60/50 frames per second. A wider range of screen sizes is now available as well, and prices are dipping (though still not quite at a level suitable for mainstream consumption).

Of course, the lack of 4K content is one of the often cited reasons against 4K TVs. In the U.S., Sony sells a US$700 media player that stores and plays 4K movies and TV shows downloaded from the company’s Video Unlimited 4K service, but it only works with Sony’s 4K TVs. Surely, if 4K content is hard to come by in the U.S. (at least providers there like Amazon, Comcast, and Fox have announced plans to deliver 4K video), you can imagine how much worse it’s for us here.

On another related note, while we’re glad to see more affordable 4K TVs, be reminded that this is because manufacturers are churning out 4K TVs with smaller screen sizes, such as Samsung’s HU7000 series, which starts at 40 inches. In our experience, buying a 4K TV below 65 inches to play 1080p content is a waste of money; you’re better off buying a 1080p set of the same size. Assuming you’ve 4K content, buying a small 4K TV doesn’t make a lot of sense either, since you’ve to sit very close to it to notice the improvement.

 

Introducing the Samsung HU9000 & HU8500

With that out of the way, it’s time to dive into this review, which actually covers two 4K TVs, the Samsung HU9000 and HU8500. The HU9000 comes in 55, 65, and 78-inch screen sizes, but are otherwise identical in specs. The same goes for the HU8500, which comes in 48, 55, and 65-inch screen sizes. For this review, we’ve hurled in the 65-inch model of each series.

Although the HU9000 and HU8500 differ very little in specs (more on that later), they’re worlds apart in the looks department. You see, the HU9000 is a curved 4K TV, whereas the HU8500 is your regular flatscreen 4K TV. While not the sole reason, the HU9000’s curved panel is without doubt the biggest contributor to the approximately PhP 200,000 price difference between the two TVs. The UA65HU9000K is estimated to be priced between PhP 300,000 and PhP 500,000; the UA65HU8500K is estimated between PhP 150,000 and PhP 400,000. Expensive, yes, but both are now quite a bit cheaper than when they first launched.

The more important question is: Is the HU9000 worth the premium?

To get the curved HU9000 (above) or the flat HU8500 (below), that's the question today.

 

Design

 

HU9000

The HU9000 is marketed as the world’s first curved 4K TV, and has a curvature of 4,200R (that is, the curve of a circle with a radius of 4,200mm). While this number sounds big, the curve is actually pretty slight, so much so that it still fits in the same box that its same-size flatscreen sibling comes in.

According to Samsung, 4,200mm is chosen because the resulting curvature works well with the average TV viewing distance, which is about 3 to 4m. But let’s be clear upfront: at that distance and especially when seated in the sweet spot down the center, we found the HU9000 as immersive as the non-curved HU8500. It’s really more of a size factor than anything else. It goes without saying that the curvature is more noticeable from the sides; and if you were to ask Samsung (or any other curved TV maker), off-center viewing is one area that a curved TV fares better than a flatscreen TV. We’ll check out if that’s really the case further down this review.

To best recreate the floating TV illusion, we suggest wall-mounting the HU9000, which can be done with standard VESA brackets or Samsung’s very own WMN450M mini wall mount. For putting on the TV racks, the silver brushed metal stand, which sports a matching curve, is thin, unobtrusive, and inconspicuous.

In short, the HU9000 is really a stunning looking piece of kit, even when the screen is off.

A curved, non-swivel base stand to match the curved screen.

 

HU8500

In short, design-wise, the HU8500 is the flat version of the HU9000. Cosmetic differences compared to the HU9000 include a slightly thinner matte black bezel (8mm vs. 10mm; or 9.5mm vs. 13mm if you measure all the way to the side trim), a silver brushed metal finish for the trim (vs. glossy chrome on the HU9000), and a more plasticky rear cover. The non-swivel stand is given the same brushed metal treatment just like the HU9000’s stand, but minus the arc, of course.

The HU8500 doesn't use the external One Connect box; all the connections are found on the back of the cabinet.

 

One Connect box (a.k.a. UHD Evolution Kit)

The HU9000 comes with this longish One Connect box, which strange as it might sound, houses the brains of the TV, and all the input/output ports. This clever implementation basically means that you can perform hardware and software upgrades to the TV down the road without having to throw out the TV entirely.

However, for the HU8500, all the hardware components are housed within its chassis, with the I/Os at the rear. The back does sport a One Connect jack, so upgrades can be done by connecting to future One Connect boxes.

Out of the box, both TVs support the latest standards, including HEVC, HDMI 2.0, MHL 3.0, and HDCP 2.2.

One of the reasons why the curved HU9000 can be so thin is because many of its hardware components are housed inside this One Connect box.

Don't fret if you don't see any ports on the back of the HU9000; they are all found on the external One Connect box, including four HDMI ports and a LAN jack.

On the side sit more jacks: USB 3.0, USB 2.0 (two of them), IR out, and optical digital audio out.

 

TV Accessory Kit

 

HU9000

Packed together with the HU9000 is another black gift box-style case that neatly holds the user manuals, power cord, Samsung’s latest smart TV remote control (Samsung calls it Smart Control), two pairs of active 3D glasses, an IR extender cable (if you want to use the remote to control other equipment that rely on IR commands), as well as component and composite AV cables (which plug into the One Connect box, obviously). There’s even a piece of cleaning cloth, and some plastic adapters that are only used if you’re wall-mounting the TV.

The accessory kit box that comes with the HU9000 is much nicer...

 

HU8500

By contrast, the brown box that’s the HU8500’s TV accessory kit looks and feels less premium, and packs fewer items. We’ve the usual user manuals, power cord, the same Smart Control, two pairs of 3D glasses, and an IR extender cable.

...than the one that comes with the HU8500. By all accounts, the HU8500 is very much a high-end TV; but it's made to feel like a second-class citizen here.

 

2014 Smart Control

Connected via Bluetooth (so line of sight isn’t required), the silver color (with a black brushed metal-like faceplate) Smart Control remote that both the HU9000 and HU8500 come with sports an elongated oval design, with a slight curve for a better fit in the hand.

For navigation, the highlight this time round is a new button console with four direction keys and a touchpad in the center. Unlike a notebook’s trackpad, you don’t scrub the Smart Control’s touchpad to move the cursor. Instead, the motion control system kicks in the moment you place a finger on the touchpad, and the cursor moves when you move the Smart Control - you know, like a wand. Naturally, not all menus support the touchpad, which is why we still have the four arrow keys. In addition, the touchpad is handy for scrolling webpages, and doubles up as an Enter button (when you press it).

Being a small remote also means that some keys have to be omitted. While dedicated media transport keys (rewind, play, pause, fast-forward) are still around, you won’t see any number keys. For entering digits and other commands not found on the Smart Control, you’ve to turn to the standard remote or onscreen virtual remote, which is activated by pressing the Keypad button on the Smart Control.

Both 4K TVs come with a smart remote and a standard remote.

If you misplace the standard remote (please don't), you can turn to the onscreen remote.